Brother Printer Comparison NZ: HL-L3240CDW vs HL-L8240CDW vs DCP-L3560CDW vs MFC-L3755CDW, MFC-L3760CDW & MFC-L8390CDW
Choosing the right Brother colour printer involves more than comparing the purchase price. For New Zealand home offices, small businesses and professional workplaces, factors such as print speed, multifunction features, paper handling, connectivity, toner yield and long-term running costs can make a significant difference.
The Brother HL-L3240CDW, HL-L8240CDW, DCP-L3560CDW, MFC-L3755CDW, MFC-L3760CDW and MFC-L8390CDW are six closely related A4 colour LED/laser printers, but each is designed around a slightly different type of user.
A major advantage for buyers comparing these models is the availability of the Brother TN258/TN258XL toner family. MyToner lists compatible and genuine TN258 options for the printer models covered in this guide, making toner availability an important part of the comparison.
Brother Printer Comparison at a Glance
| Printer | Type | Copy | Scan | Fax | ADF | Approx. Colour/Mono Speed | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HL-L3240CDW | Colour printer | ✓ | — | — | — | — | Up to 26 ppm |
| HL-L8240CDW | Professional colour printer | ✓ | — | — | — | — | Up to 30+ ppm class |
| DCP-L3560CDW | Multifunction | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | — | ✓ | Up to 26 ppm |
| MFC-L3755CDW | Multifunction | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | Up to 26 ppm |
| MFC-L3760CDW | Multifunction | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | Up to 26 ppm |
| MFC-L8390CDW | Professional multifunction | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | Up to 30 ppm |
Brother’s current NZ range confirms the HL-L3240CDW, DCP-L3560CDW, HL-L8240CDW, MFC-L3760CDW, MFC-L3755CDW and MFC-L8390CDW as colour A4 models, with the latter professional models designed for more demanding business environments.
1. Brother HL-L3240CDW: Compact Colour Printing
The Brother HL-L3240CDW is the simplest option in this comparison because it concentrates on printing rather than combining printing with scanning and copying.
Brother describes it as a compact colour LED printer designed for homes and small offices. It provides colour and monochrome printing, automatic two-sided A4 printing, USB, LAN and Wi-Fi connectivity, and print speeds of up to 26 pages per minute.
This makes the HL-L3240CDW particularly suitable for:
- Home offices
- Small businesses
- Invoices and reports
- Colour presentations
- Everyday A4 documents
- Users who already have a separate scanner
For toner, MyToner lists the HL-L3240CDW as compatible with its premium compatible TN258 cartridges. The cyan cartridge, for example, is rated at approximately 1,000 pages at 5% A4 coverage.
Shop Premium Compatible Brother TN258 Cyan Toner for this printer.
2. Brother HL-L8240CDW: Professional Colour Printing
The Brother HL-L8240CDW moves into the professional colour printer category.
It is particularly relevant for businesses that want a dedicated printer rather than an all-in-one multifunction machine. That can be useful when scanning and copying are handled elsewhere in the office.
Brother’s NZ range describes the HL-L8240CDW as a compact professional colour laser printer.
The HL-L8240CDW can be considered when you need:
- Business colour printing
- Network printing
- Automatic duplex printing
- Higher-volume document production
- Professional reports and presentations
- A dedicated office printer
MyToner’s genuine Brother TN258XL Toner Combo Value Pack lists the HL-L8240CDW as a compatible printer.
3. Brother DCP-L3560CDW: Print, Copy and Scan
If you want more than printing, the Brother DCP-L3560CDW is a significant step up from the HL-L3240CDW.
The DCP designation indicates that this is a multifunction printer providing printing, copying and scanning. Brother’s product information places it in its compact colour multifunction range.
The DCP-L3560CDW is designed around a 26 ppm print speed and provides the functions required by many home offices and small businesses.
It can be a practical choice for users who regularly need to:
- Scan signed documents
- Copy invoices
- Print customer paperwork
- Scan identification or forms
- Produce colour reports
- Print double-sided documents
For businesses, having copy and scan functions in the same machine can reduce the need for separate office equipment.
The DCP-L3560CDW is also listed by MyToner as compatible with the TN258XL toner family.
Explore the wider Brother toner range at MyToner for additional Brother printer supplies.
4. Brother MFC-L3755CDW: A Complete Small-Office Printer
The Brother MFC-L3755CDW adds fax capability to the print, copy and scan functionality.
According to Brother’s product guide, the MFC-L3755CDW provides colour and monochrome printing, copying, scanning and faxing, with print speeds of up to 26 ppm.
The MFC series can therefore be more appropriate for offices that still exchange documents by fax or need a traditional multifunction workflow.
Key functions include:
- Colour printing
- Black-and-white printing
- Copying
- Scanning
- Fax
- Automatic duplex printing
- Automatic document feeding
- Network connectivity
MyToner lists the MFC-L3755CDW among the compatible printers for its genuine Brother TN258XL combo pack.
For businesses that want to keep spare cartridges available, purchasing the complete CMYK set can simplify toner inventory.
5. Brother MFC-L3760CDW: Connected Multifunction Printing
The MFC-L3760CDW is another compact colour multifunction printer, but it adds a particularly strong combination of connectivity and document-handling features.
Brother specifies:
- Up to 26 pages per minute
- 250-sheet paper capacity
- Automatic duplex printing
- 50-sheet ADF
- 8.76 cm colour touchscreen
- Gigabit Ethernet
- 2.4 GHz/5 GHz Wi-Fi
- USB 2.0
- Desktop, USB and mobile printing/scanning
- High-yield replacement toner options
The 50-sheet automatic document feeder is important if you frequently scan or copy multi-page documents.
Instead of placing each sheet individually on the scanner glass, multiple sheets can be loaded into the ADF.
This makes the MFC-L3760CDW worth considering for:
- Accountants
- Property managers
- Trades businesses
- Home offices
- Small retailers
- Administrative teams
- Professional services
MyToner specifically lists the MFC-L3760CDW among the printers supported by its TN258XL toner products.
6. Brother MFC-L8390CDW: Professional Multifunction Printing
The MFC-L8390CDW is the most business-oriented multifunction printer in this comparison.
Brother specifies print speeds of up to 30 pages per minute, a 250-sheet paper capacity expandable to 500 sheets with optional trays, Gigabit Ethernet, dual-band Wi-Fi, USB connectivity and NFC authentication. It also has automatic two-sided printing and scanning and a 50-sheet duplex ADF.
This makes it particularly relevant to workplaces where several employees share the same printer.
Another significant difference is its toner capacity. Brother lists super-high-yield replacement toner options of up to 4,500 black pages and 4,000 colour pages for this model.
The MFC-L8390CDW is therefore worth investigating when printer downtime and frequent cartridge replacement are concerns.
MyToner lists the MFC-L8390CDW as compatible with its Genuine Brother TN258XL Toner Combo Value Pack.
Brother TN258 Toner: What Supplies Do These Printers Use?
One of the most important SEO and buying considerations when comparing these printers is the TN258 toner family.
MyToner’s product listings identify the following models as compatible with TN258 supplies:
- Brother HL-L3240CDW
- Brother HL-L8240CDW
- Brother DCP-L3560CDW
- Brother MFC-L3755CDW
- Brother MFC-L3760CDW
- Brother MFC-L8390CDW
The standard TN258 cartridges are available in:
- Black
- Cyan
- Magenta
- Yellow
MyToner currently lists its premium compatible TN258 cyan and magenta cartridges at approximately 1,000 pages each, based on the stated 5% A4 coverage measurement.
For customers wanting all four colours together, MyToner also lists a Premium Compatible Brother TN258 4-Colour Toner Cartridge Pack, while its genuine TN258XL value pack provides another supply option.
Standard TN258 vs TN258XL Toner
When buying Brother toner, it is important not to compare cartridges solely by their purchase price.
A lower-priced standard cartridge may have a lower page yield, while an XL cartridge can provide more pages before replacement.
For businesses printing regularly, the more useful calculation is:
Cost per page = cartridge price ÷ expected page yield
For example, a business printing thousands of pages every month may benefit from purchasing higher-capacity cartridges because fewer replacements can mean less administration and less interruption.
MyToner’s Brother high-capacity information also discusses the relationship between higher page yields, cost per page and reduced cartridge replacement frequency.
Genuine Brother Toner vs Compatible Toner
Another important consideration is whether to buy genuine Brother toner or a compatible replacement.
Genuine Brother toner
Genuine cartridges are manufactured for Brother printers and can be useful for customers who specifically want OEM consumables.
MyToner lists the Genuine Brother TN258XL Toner Combo Value Pack for this printer family.
Compatible toner
Compatible toner cartridges provide another option for buyers primarily concerned with replacement costs.
MyToner’s FAQ states that its compatible cartridges are manufactured to match the required cartridge dimensions and that cartridges requiring chips are supplied with chips.
For example, the Premium Compatible Brother TN258 Magenta is listed as a 1,000-page compatible cartridge for all six printer models in this comparison.
Don’t Forget Brother Printer Drums and Other Supplies
Toner is not the only consumable worth considering when calculating the long-term cost of a Brother colour printer.
Depending on the printer and its maintenance requirements, businesses should also consider replacement drums and other printer supplies.
MyToner has a dedicated Brother Drum Units section, alongside its broader Brother toner range. The MyToner shop currently lists Brother as one of its largest product categories, with separate toner and drum products.
For customers using Brother label printers alongside office printers, MyToner also carries Brother Label Tapes and other Brother label supplies.
Which Brother Printer Is Right for You?
The choice ultimately depends on how you work.
Choose the HL-L3240CDW if you need:
Compact colour printing without multifunction features.
It is designed for users who mainly print and do not require an integrated scanner, copier or fax.
Choose the HL-L8240CDW if you need:
A professional dedicated colour printer.
It is better suited to a business environment where printing is the primary requirement.
Choose the DCP-L3560CDW if you need:
Printing, copying and scanning.
It provides the core multifunction features without the fax functionality of the MFC models.
Choose the MFC-L3755CDW if you need:
Print, copy, scan and fax in one machine.
It can suit small offices where fax remains part of the document workflow.
Choose the MFC-L3760CDW if you need:
A connected compact multifunction printer with a 50-sheet ADF.
Its dual-band Wi-Fi, Ethernet, touchscreen and mobile connectivity make it suitable for modern office workflows.
Choose the MFC-L8390CDW if you need:
A faster professional multifunction printer for a busier office.
Its 30 ppm-class speed, duplex scanning, expandable paper capacity and higher-yield toner options distinguish it from the more compact models.
Brother Printer Supplies in New Zealand
For New Zealand buyers, checking toner availability before purchasing a printer is a smart part of the buying process.
A printer may have an attractive purchase price, but the ongoing cost of consumables can become more important over several years.
MyToner provides a dedicated Brother toner cartridge category containing a broad range of Brother toner products. The site also offers Brother ink and toner supplies, compatible cartridges, genuine options and other printing consumables.
For users with multiple Brother printers, buying supplies from the same range can also simplify stock management.
Final Brother HL vs DCP vs MFC Comparison
The six printers covered in this guide occupy different positions within the Brother colour printer range.
The HL-L3240CDW is focused on compact colour printing, while the HL-L8240CDW provides a more professional dedicated printing solution.
The DCP-L3560CDW adds copying and scanning, making it useful for home offices and small businesses.
The MFC-L3755CDW and MFC-L3760CDW add fax and automatic document handling, while the MFC-L8390CDW moves further toward professional business printing with faster output, duplex scanning, expandable paper capacity and higher-capacity toner options.
The toner situation is particularly useful for buyers comparing these models. MyToner lists the TN258/TN258XL family across all six printers, giving customers multiple options when purchasing standard, high-yield, compatible or genuine supplies.
For anyone searching for Brother HL-L3240CDW toner NZ, Brother HL-L8240CDW toner, DCP-L3560CDW toner, MFC-L3755CDW toner, MFC-L3760CDW toner or MFC-L8390CDW toner, checking both printer compatibility and cartridge yield is essential before ordering.
